Bridging Theory and Practice Since 1974

Category: Travel

Two Perspectives on the Biltmore Estate

By Abby Cover and Sam Hayes

Perspective 1: Interning at the Biltmore
By Sam Hayes

My fascination with the Biltmore Estate began during a family trip when I was in first grade. Little did my parents know how deeply I would fall in love with this remarkable place. Since the first visit, it was always my dream to one day work at the Biltmore – a dream that became a reality this past summer. 

For context, the Biltmore Estate, located near Asheville, NC, was built in 1895 by George Vanderbilt, an heir to a portion of the Vanderbilt fortune. Today the Estate is owned by descendants of George Vanderbilt and is run as a tourist attraction that welcomes over a million visitors every year. 

The Estate is 8,000 acres and includes the historic house designed by architect Richard Morris Hunt, gardens and grounds designed by Frederick Law Olmstead, several operational farms, a winery, dozens of residences, a company run police force, and a modern “village” with hotels, restaurants, and shops. The Biltmore Company, which owns Biltmore Estate and several other subsidiary companies, employs over 2,000 people in Asheville. Needless to say, the Estate operates like a small city.

Biltmore Estate, Source: Sam Hayes

During my time at the Biltmore, I was given free range to explore the Estate and engage with those responsible for its operations. My supervisor, Parker Andes, is the head of estate planning and is a wealth of knowledge. He oversees all construction projects on the Estate, and having dedicated two decades to the Biltmore, he has seen the evolution of the Estate. 

The mission of the Biltmore company is “The preservation of Biltmore as a privately owned, profitable, working estate.” Historic preservation is an important part of the work done on the Estate. As I delved deeper into the workings of the company, I discovered that there are many different reasons why preservation is valued at the company. Some employees find pride in safeguarding such a monumental piece of history. In contrast, higher-ups in the company emphasize the financial incentives as a primary driver for ongoing preservation efforts. 

Archive Room in the Biltmore Estate, Source: Sam Hayes

The Biltmore holds the distinction of being a National Historic Landmark, the highest designation from the federal government for historic sites. To retain the historic landmark status, elements of the Estate cannot be altered without approval from the North Carolina State Historic Preservation Office, and ultimately, the National Parks Service. Maintaining this National Historic Landmark Status is a key priority for the Biltmore Company because it allows them to obtain tax credits for certain historic rehabilitation projects done on the Estate. Though this is just one element of a broader rationale for preservation, I think that this shows that as long as there is a financial reason for the Biltmore Company to maintain the historic integrity of the Estate, it will continue to be preserved. 

I’ve spent a lot of time thinking about my experience at the Biltmore. It was a unique opportunity and I don’t regret doing it, but I also realized that I do not want to work for a private company. I need a broader mission behind what I’m doing – something that makes me excited to get up in the morning. Regardless, the Biltmore continues to have a special place in my heart. 

Perspective 2: Vacationing at the Biltmore
By Abby Cover

This summer, I spent three days in Asheville, specifically staying at the Inn at Biltmore. The Biltmore Estate itself is only a small part of the total grounds, which total about 8,000 acres, and the Inn is located toward the far end of the grounds. From the entrance of the grounds, it takes about 10 minutes to drive to the Inn. This makes the Inn very secluded, but also makes you dependent on The Biltmore for such things as food and entertainment. Surprisingly, there is little in terms of trails accessible at the Inn (to my knowledge), so you are definitely meant to stay inside the Inn (or go to the nearby Antler Village) to entertain yourself. Antler Village at The Biltmore is a hotel and a clustering of restaurants and shops that opened in 2010, located down the hill from The Inn.

Front of Biltmore Estate, Source: Abby Cover

The Inn at the Biltmore is intended to be more of a resort than a hotel, but there are not many amenities besides a beautiful view keeping you at the “resort.” I was disappointed by the lack of ability to walk around the Biltmore grounds while staying at the Inn – there are trails, but they need to be driven to, or are not clearly marked as walkable from the Inn. Antler Village does have some activities similar to a historical town, such as a woodworking and weaving, which is interesting if you are there at the right time. Also, the Village has outdoor activities scheduled such as sheepdog herding (which I was disappointed to have missed). There are additional activities that can be purchased according to a little slip of paper given to us, along with general Biltmore and Asheville information, upon check in. Eating at the Inn requires sitting down and being waited on in the hotel restaurant, which I personally was not used to for breakfast in particular. Sometimes you (I) just want a continental breakfast! The facilities themselves were lovely, and the hotel staff were helpful and kind. Also, you get a free coffee table book about the history of the Estate, which is very cool!

Biltmore Estate Gardens, Source: Abby Cover

The Estate itself was enormous and beautiful – the self-guided walking tour took about two hours! Definitely a workout if you’re not prepared; you have to climb the basement stairs and then go all the way to the top! There is a well-organized line for the self-guided tours that is very reminiscent of the lines in theme parks, like Disney World. I was impressed at how efficient the line was, though it was not in the shade and Asheville is hot in the summer. Very sweaty. Once in the Estate itself, it is undeniably beautiful. However, for myself, it’s frankly unbelievable and sometimes a little uncomfortable being around such blatant demonstrations of wealth. You could probably do both the house tour and explore the gardens of the Estate in one day, but it would be a very full day. However, to explore the full 8,000 acres, there is absolutely no way to do that in one day. Pre-planning is definitely needed in order to explore the full Biltmore grounds.

Overall, I enjoyed my stay at the Biltmore Inn, but think it is not necessary if you want to explore the Biltmore grounds or Estate! The grounds are so enormous and well maintained, and the house is truly extraordinary, and I am glad I visited.


Sam Hayes is a second-year master’s student in the City and Regional Planning program at the University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill. At UNC-CH, he specializes in housing and community development with an emphasis on how historic preservation can be used as an anti-gentrification tactic in changing communities. Sam loves hiking, reading, and spending time exploring cool historic buildings. When not in Chapel Hill, you will probably find Sam in Hendersonville, NC with his boyfriend Kane, dog Canyon, and cat Lucille.

Abby is in her second year of the City and Regional Planning Master’s Program, and is looking forward to sharing all she has learned with her future employers. She previously studied Sociology and Gender, Sexuality, and Women’s Studies at the University of Pittsburgh. Before coming to UNC, Abby could be found galivanting through her native Philadelphia (Go Birds!). Her planning interests include climate adaptations, sustainable development, and fostering community engagement. Outside of planning you can find her grabbing a bagel sandwich, watching horror movies, and wishing for better public transit.


Edited by Kathryn Cunningham

Featured image courtesy of Sam Hayes

Series: Planning for 36 Hours in Guangzhou, China 

Planner’s Travel Series 

About the series: Welcome to our ongoing travel series. These are all posts written by planning students and professionals about what to do in a given city when looking for Brunch, a Brew, or a good idea on a Budget. To cap it all off, we include a fun planning fact!   

By Yue Zhang


About the visit: When people ask me where my hometown is, I would usually describe it as a city located near Hong Kong. One stereotype is that China only has three major cities: Beijing, Shanghai and Hong Kong. However, Guangzhou is the largest city in Southern China and has a history of more than 2,200 years! During the summertime, I went home and had a really lovely time. Through the 36 Hours series, I hope you all can have an immersive experience of this beautiful modern city. Here are some of my favorite spots:

Brunch  

Har Gow (Chinese shrimp dumplings) at Tao Tao Ju.   

Yum cha is the traditional brunch including dim sum and Chinese tea in the Canton area. Small portions of steamed or pan-fried dim sum served in bamboo steamers and hot Chinese tea are a perfect match to start your day. One of my must-eat dim sum is har gow. Chopped or entire shrimp, pork fat and bamboo shoots are wrapped by translucent and chewy skin. It has a very rich, umami taste. Each plate costs about 30 RMB which is around 5 dollars. I would also recommend cheung fun (steamed rice noodle rolls) and egg tarts. All of them are very affordable and you could always share them with your friends and family.

Brew  

Shuang Pi Nai (the two at the bottom of the picture) at Meigui Desserts

Shuang Pi Nai (double skin milk) is a Cantonese dessert made of milk, egg whites, and sugar. The dessert has two skins:  the first skin forms during the cooling of the boiled milk and the second forms when the prepared custard cools. I would prefer to add red beans on it, but you could also add other toppings like mango chunks, sago, etc. It tastes velvety and sweet and only costs 10 RMB which is about 2 dollars!

Budget 

The Statue of Five Goats in Yuexiu Park

Guangzhou is also called “City of Five Goats” because of an ancient Chinese mythology. It is said that there were five gods who appeared to give wheat to the people and left five goats to prevent famine and drought. Therefore ancient Guangzhou was able to rebuild. Yuexiu Park is a perfect place to go if you want to explore the history of Guangzhou and explore nature a little bit. You could also find the site of the Ming Dynasty City Wall, Zhenhai Tower, and other cool places to see in the park (it’s free admission)!

Fun Planning Fact 

Urban villages in Guangzhou

Guangzhou has nearly 138 urban villages. They are products of the dual-land tenure system which divides the residential areas into household registration agricultural and non-agricultural. The dual-land tenure system was intended to preserve rural areas from being encroached upon but it led to rural-urban migration which increased pressure on urban cities to expand. There are a lot of urban problems like substandard health and building quality as well as higher crime rate in urban villages. The government has decided to regenerate those villages but there is still some controversy..

Featured Image: Canton Tower in Guangzhou. Photo Credit: Yue Zhang 


Yue is a first year Master’s student in the Department of City and Regional Planning whose specialization is Land Use and Environmental Policy. She earned her B.E. in Civil Engineering back in China. She enjoys hiking, watching movies and drinking boba in her free time.

Series: Planning for 36 Hours in Durham, North Carolina

Planner’s Travel Series 

This post was originally published on June 22, 2022, but the brunch, brew, and budget options for Durham, North Carolina are still relevant today!


About the series: Welcome to our ongoing travel series. These are all posts written by planning students and professionals about what to do in a given city when looking for Brunch, a Brew, or a good idea on a Budget. To cap it all off, we include a fun planning fact!   

By Henry Read


About the visit: I’ve lived in Durham for four and a half years, including my time at UNC-DCRP. It’s a fun town, and it has grown by leaps and bounds even in the short time I’ve been around. Between the diverse population, the acclaimed universities, the expansive parks, and the ever-evolving nightlife, there is a little something for everyone’s taste here. Whether you’re looking for a night out or a place to make a home outside of the Chapel Hill bubble, Durham is worth checking out. 

Brunch  

1

Geer Street Garden, all set up for brunch 

My preferred brunch spot in Durham is definitely Geer Street Garden. From 11 to 4 on Sundays, this longstanding neighborhood bar and grill eschews its usual menu and serves up an incredible all-you-can-eat buffet featuring all the southern classics, from grits and gravy to deviled eggs to banana pudding. Booze isn’t included with the meal, but their mimosas are cheap, and their bloody marys are strong and come with a kaleidoscope of garnish options. To top it off Geer Street Garden has one of the nicest patios in town, so you are assured of quality ambiance as you nurse your drink and pick at your third plate of chilaquiles amidst the trumpet vine and honeysuckle at this Old North Durham standby. 

Brew  

2

Someone enjoying a brandy flip at the bar at Kingfisher’s 

In the latter third of the 20th century, Durham suffered from a reputation as a difficult town to find a drink in. But it is hard to imagine that in 2022; the bar and brewery scene in the contemporary Bull City is varied and ubiquitous.

For beer lovers, Fullsteam Brewing Company is a must-see. They are the oldest operation in the city, and for my money far and away by far from the best. Their core set covers all the major styles of American and European beer from tripels to pilsners, but where Fullsteam REALLY shines are their limited-run foraged beers. These small-batch runs are made with locally sourced fruits and botanicals, and consistently combine creativity and drinkability in remarkable ways – if you are in town in the fall, be sure to pick up a pawpaw IPA.

Cocktail enthusiasts in Durham have a range of excellent options available as well. The Accordion Club is a mainstay of the service industry set in the Geer Street nightlife district and serves heavy pours and legendary loaded fritos to everywhere else’s bartenders on their days off. And for a higher-end experience, Kingfishers has both the ambiance and the artistry to engage even the most jaded pallet. Located right next door to the midcentury masterpiece that is the Durham Hotel, this basement retreat is no dive – the ever-evolving menu of artisanal concoctions is matched perfectly by the luxurious private booths and the truly talented jazz quartet.

Budget 

3

One of the older sections of Duke Gardens in late summer 

Despite its rising fortunes in the last few decades, there is still some cheap fun to be had in Durham, if you know where to look. Every Friday night talented young Ddurhamites gather in CCB Plaza for Med City Cypher, an improvisational expression of rap, singing, and beat making. More collaborative than a battle but more polished than an impromptu meetup, this rolling group performance is guaranteed to inspire and is open for all to observe and participate.

One of the fringe benefits of playing host to a world-renowned university like Duke is access to its cultural resources, and Durham has its share. The Sarah P. Duke Botanical Gardens are host to an incredible display of natural beauty from all around the world and are worth a visit in any season; entry is free, though parking is not. For the more artistically inclined, Duke Coffeehouse hosts musical acts from around the country and the world in an extremely intimate setting at the edge of the old campus, always BYOB and usually for under $5 a head. The venue is fully student-run but is funded by the university, attracting, and paying for some truly innovative concerts.

Movieloft cleaves to a similar DIY aesthetic as Duke Coffeehouse, with the additional authenticity of being a completely independent concern. Meeting on the third Thursday of every month in a photography studio at the Ample Storage Center, this underground film club screens cult classics and grindhouse delight unavailable on any streaming service. The festivities start at 7 with a potluck cookout and a DJ set inspired by the evening’s movie. The film rolls around 8, and is free to anyone who can find it within the maze of storage bays. Drinks are provided as well, though only a real jerk would tap the keg without throwing a few bucks in the bin to keep the lights on.

Fun Planning Fact 

4

Brightleaf Square, the Watts and Yuille warehouses, post-redevelopment 

Durham was a leader in the now ubiquitous practice of tobacco warehouse renovations into live-work spaces. Beginning with the Watts and Yuille warehouses in 1980, much of the city’s downtown industrial buildings have been converted into shops, offices, and apartments. And it is easy to see why the trend kicked off here; the attention to detail exhibited in the neo-Romanesque brickwork of the 1890s warehouses is an architectural marvel. These renovation projects proved to be a great economic success as well, and today these once derelict but now vibrant buildings are an essential component of Durham’s urban form.

Featured Image: Durham’s downtown skyline, facing north from the North Carolina Railroad. Photo Credit: Henry Read. 


Henry Read graduated from the Department of City and Regional Planning in 2023. He is fascinated with the minutia of development regulation and doesn’t understand why so many people think zoning is boring. He hopes to work in the public sector after graduation and would like to be remembered as the guy who got your town to stop requiring bars to have customer parking and start planting native fruit trees in parks. 

Announcing the Winner of the 2023 Winter Photo Contest & CPJ Cover Photo contest!

After a close competition, we are pleased to share the winning submission to this year’s Carolina Angles photo contest. Christy Fierros captured this image overlooking Tucson, Arizona, and shares her thoughts on its meaning below.

Christy’s winning photo will also be featured in Volume 48 of the Carolina Planning Journal, Urban Analytics, coming this spring. Thank you to everyone who participated, and congratulations to Christy!


The Catalina Mountains and ancient Saguaros witness an area in constant flux. After the Gadsden Purchase of 1854 annexed this area of Mexico into the United States, “The Old Pueblo” grew. While urban renewal schemes are well-known in many east-coast cities, few are recognized in the Southwest. In the 1960’s, Downtown (pictured), was targeted by the City in their “slum clearance” project. The nearly 400-acre area destroyed was multi-ethnic, but predominantly Chicanx and had walkable neighborhoods with adobe homes, small grocers, and shops—exactly the mix of uses that millions of dollars are being spent to emulate today.

As more people move to Tucson for its affordability, arid climate, and economic opportunities, the city grapples with improving its transportation systems. Tucson recently acquired federal funds to implement equitable Transit-Oriented Development (eTOD). A Bus Rapid Transit (BRT) system is proposed from this funding with a route crossing through areas of south Tucson where the median household income is $32K and rents are rapidly rising. While an improved public transit system and more dense development is badly needed, the BRT system represents a new spatial conflict for Tucson’s working-class who more often than not, bear the burden of land use decisions while others reap the benefits.

Many new, mixed-use and transit-oriented developments in the city core cater to higher income folks, university students, and tourists. The BRT project and new developments surrounding historic barrios look like gentrification to many communities in South Tucson. Mi Barrio No Se Vende (“My Neighborhood Is Not For Sale”) yard signs are scattered throughout. While the eTOD funding promises to expand affordable housing to prevent displacement, many hope history doesn’t repeat and the project funding stays true to its name.

Christy Fierros is a first-generation master’s student in the Department of City and Regional Planning specializing in Land Use and Environmental planning. She received a dual bachelor’s degree from the University of Arizona in Environmental Studies and Geography. She is passionate about making environmental injustices nonexistent and planning practices rooted in repair and respect. Hiking, bird watching, gardening, or looking at trees are just a few things that replenish her after a long day at the computer.


Looking for another opportunity to share your work? Submit to the CPJ Cover Photo contest!

The Carolina Planning Journal is now accepting submissions for the cover photo of this year’s journal, and we’d love to feature your image! Submissions should be related to this year’s journal theme, Urban Analytics: Capabilities and Critiques. Examples of previous cover images can be found at the journal’s online repository. If your photo is selected for the cover, you will receive $100 for the rights to use it in the journal as well as photo attribution.

To enter submit your high-resolution (min. 300 dpi) photo to carolinaplanningjournal@gmail.com with the subject “CPJ Cover Photo Submission,” along with a brief explanation of how your image relates to the journal’s theme. Contact the Journal with any further questions.

Your 2022-23 Editors:

LANCE GLOSS | Editor-in-Chief & JO KWON | Managing Editor

Lance is a second-generation urban planner with a passion for economic development strategies that center natural resource conservation and community uplift. He served as Managing Editor of the Urban Journal at Brown University, Section Editor at the College Hill Independent, and Senior Planner for the City of Grand Junction. Hailing from sunny Colorado, he earned his BA in Urban Studies at Brown and will earn his Master’s in City and Regional Planning in 2023. Jo (Joungwon) is a fourth-year Ph.D. student in City and Regional Planning with an interest in using visuals in environmental planning. She has been a part of CPJ since 2019. With a background in Statistics and English Literature, she received her M.A. in Computational Media at Duke University.

Announcing the Carolina Angles Winter Photo Contest

Do you have winter travel plans? Preparing for a holiday staycation? Either way, Carolina Angles invites you to participate in our Winter Photo Contest!

We encourage UNC planning students, alumni, and all urban enthusiasts to enter. Photos will be judged based on aesthetics as well as the articulated connection to planning.

The photographer of the winning photo will receive:

  • Recognition in the Carolina Planning Journal and Angles blog
  • Pre-order of Volume 48 of the Carolina Planning Journal, Urban Analytics (published in Spring 2023)
  • Carolina Planning Journal swag

Please use this google form to submit your photo and a brief blurb with how it relates to planning by Friday, January 27, 2023 at 5:00pm.

We look forward to your entries!

Featured Image courtesy of Duncan Richey’s Snowbird, Utah

Series: Planning for 36 Hours in Durham, North Carolina

Planner’s Travel Series 

About the series: Welcome to our ongoing travel series. These are all posts written by planning students and professionals about what to do in a given city when looking for Brunch, a Brew, or a good idea on a Budget. To cap it all off, we include a fun planning fact!   

By Henry Read


About the visit: I’ve lived in Durham for four and a half years, including my time at UNC-DCRP. It’s a fun town, and it has grown by leaps and bounds even in the short time I’ve been around. Between the diverse population, the acclaimed universities, the expansive parks, and the ever-evolving nightlife, there is a little something for everyone’s taste here. Whether you’re looking for a night out or a place to make a home outside of the Chapel Hill bubble, Durham is worth checking out. 

Brunch  

1

Geer Street Garden, all set up for brunch 

My preferred brunch spot in Durham is definitely Geer Street Garden. From 11 to 4 on Sundays, this longstanding neighborhood bar and grill eschews its usual menu and serves up an incredible all-you-can-eat buffet featuring all the southern classics, from grits and gravy to deviled eggs to banana pudding. Booze isn’t included with the meal, but their mimosas are cheap, and their bloody marys are strong and come with a kaleidoscope of garnish options. To top it off Geer Street Garden has one of the nicest patios in town, so you are assured of quality ambiance as you nurse your drink and pick at your third plate of chilaquiles amidst the trumpet vine and honeysuckle at this Old North Durham standby. 

Brew  

2

Someone enjoying a brandy flip at the bar at Kingfisher’s 

In the latter third of the 20th century, Durham suffered from a reputation as a difficult town to find a drink in. But it is hard to imagine that in 2022; the bar and brewery scene in the contemporary Bull City is varied and ubiquitous.

For beer lovers, Fullsteam Brewing Company is a must-see. They are the oldest operation in the city, and for my money far and away by far from the best. Their core set covers all the major styles of American and European beer from tripels to pilsners, but where Fullsteam REALLY shines are their limited-run foraged beers. These small-batch runs are made with locally sourced fruits and botanicals, and consistently combine creativity and drinkability in remarkable ways – if you are in town in the fall, be sure to pick up a pawpaw IPA.

Cocktail enthusiasts in Durham have a range of excellent options available as well. The Accordion Club is a mainstay of the service industry set in the Geer Street nightlife district and serves heavy pours and legendary loaded fritos to everywhere else’s bartenders on their days off. And for a higher-end experience, Kingfishers has both the ambiance and the artistry to engage even the most jaded pallet. Located right next door to the midcentury masterpiece that is the Durham Hotel, this basement retreat is no dive – the ever-evolving menu of artisanal concoctions is matched perfectly by the luxurious private booths and the truly talented jazz quartet.

Budget 

3

One of the older sections of Duke Gardens in late summer 

Despite its rising fortunes in the last few decades, there is still some cheap fun to be had in Durham, if you know where to look. Every Friday night talented young Ddurhamites gather in CCB Plaza for Med City Cypher, an improvisational expression of rap, singing, and beat making. More collaborative than a battle but more polished than an impromptu meetup, this rolling group performance is guaranteed to inspire and is open for all to observe and participate.

One of the fringe benefits of playing host to a world-renowned university like Duke is access to its cultural resources, and Durham has its share. The Sarah P. Duke Botanical Gardens are host to an incredible display of natural beauty from all around the world and are worth a visit in any season; entry is free, though parking is not. For the more artistically inclined, Duke Coffeehouse hosts musical acts from around the country and the world in an extremely intimate setting at the edge of the old campus, always BYOB and usually for under $5 a head. The venue is fully student-run but is funded by the university, attracting, and paying for some truly innovative concerts.

Movieloft cleaves to a similar DIY aesthetic as Duke Coffeehouse, with the additional authenticity of being a completely independent concern. Meeting on the third Thursday of every month in a photography studio at the Ample Storage Center, this underground film club screens cult classics and grindhouse delight unavailable on any streaming service. The festivities start at 7 with a potluck cookout and a DJ set inspired by the evening’s movie. The film rolls around 8, and is free to anyone who can find it within the maze of storage bays. Drinks are provided as well, though only a real jerk would tap the keg without throwing a few bucks in the bin to keep the lights on.

Fun Planning Fact 

4

Brightleaf Square, the Watts and Yuille warehouses, post-redevelopment 

Durham was a leader in the now ubiquitous practice of tobacco warehouse renovations into live-work spaces. Beginning with the Watts and Yuille warehouses in 1980, much of the city’s downtown industrial buildings have been converted into shops, offices, and apartments. And it is easy to see why the trend kicked off here; the attention to detail exhibited in the neo-Romanesque brickwork of the 1890s warehouses is an architectural marvel. These renovation projects proved to be a great economic success as well, and today these once derelict but now vibrant buildings are an essential component of Durham’s urban form.

Featured Image: Durham’s downtown skyline, facing north from the North Carolina Railroad. Photo Credit: Henry Read. 


Henry Read is a Master’s student in the Department of City and Regional Planning, with a focus on land use policy. He is fascinated with the minutia of development regulation and doesn’t understand why so many people think zoning is boring. He hopes to work in the public sector after graduation and would like to be remembered as the guy who got your town to stop requiring bars to have customer parking and start planting native fruit trees in parks. 

Announcing the Winners of the 2022 Winter Photo Contest!

We had a number of excellent submissions for this year’s Carolina Angles photo contest, leading to some fierce competition! We are excited to announce three winners of this year’s contest – Ruby Brinkerhoff, Duncan Richey, and Josephine Jeni Justin. Check out their photographs below, along with their own words about its connection to planning.

Ruby’s winning photo will also be featured in Volume 47 of the Carolina Planning Journal, Planning for Healthy Cities, coming this spring. Thank you to everyone who participated, and congratulations to this year’s winners!


1st Place Winner

Title: Winter Paradise: Pennsylvania winters in an old house with a wood stove
Medium: 35mm black & white film
Artist: Ruby Brinkerhoff

As we stand with this woman in front of a large pile of firewood in need of hauling, a winter landscape in rural Pennsylvania comes into focus. Planners often portray the aerial view, yet the view from above can obscure the realities that people experience on the ground. Both perspectives, aerial and eye-level, are valuable. Understanding the immediate experience of people’s daily lives is a useful and necessary balance to the professional aesthetics and values we impose from a conceptual distance.

Ruby Brinkerhoff is a second-year Master’s student in the Department of City and Regional Planning. Ruby specializes in land use and environmental planning, with a sustained interest in food systems, climate change, and equitable access to resources. Ruby received a dual bachelor’s degree from Guilford College in Biology and Religious Studies. She loves playing music, exploring North Carolina, and all things botanical.

2nd Place Runner-Up

Title: Snowbird, Utah
Medium: 35mm color film
Artist: Duncan Richey

Little Cottonwood Canyon is home to Alta and Snowbird (pictured), two premier ski resorts that, according to some, boast “the greatest snow on Earth.” However, as nearby Salt Lake City’s population and its mountains’ popularity has grown, so has its traffic problem. The highly contentious debate to mitigate traffic in Little Cottonwood Canyon surrounds two options: a $592-million, 8-mile gondola or $510 million for enhanced bus service with a wider road.
Gondola supporters describe it as a cleaner, avalanche-proof solution that entirely avoids the treacherous road that is often clogged with traffic. Supporters of increased bus service worry that what they believe is the commonsense solution — the bus route– is getting lost in the gondola hype. The gondola, if completed, would make it the longest in the world.
Others, like Salt Lake County Mayor Jenny Wilson, ask if either solution is necessary. “I question whether we need a public investment to support two ski resorts,” said Mayor Wilson. “Might we be better off to just work with the Forest Service to put in some limits and accept that there’s 10 days a year when the snow is really coming down, the risk is too high and we just close the resorts? That, to me, is a better alternative.”
However, big changes to the canyon appear inevitable. The public comment period recently concluded on January 10, 2022 and the Utah Department of Transportation is expected to issue a final recommendation early this year.

Duncan Richey is a first-year Master’s candidate in the Department of City and Regional Planning. His academic interests include active transportation and the relationship between mental health and the built environment. When he isn’t busy with school, Duncan enjoys skiing and shooting film photography.

3rd Place Runner-Up

Title: Beach Nourishment in Florida
Medium: iPhone
Artist: Josephine Jeni Justin

Over winter break, I visited Miami, Florida. This picture was taken at the Dr. Von D. Mizell-Eula Johnson State Park where a beach nourishment project was underway. The project involved placing approximately 135,000 cubic yards of sand along 7.2 miles of critically eroded shoreline from the Port Everglades Inlet south along the State Park and along the beaches of Dania, Hollywood, and Hallendale. A wider and higher beach can provide storm protection for coastal structures, create new habitat, and enhance the beach for recreation.

Josephine Jeni Justin is a first year Master’s of City and Regional Planning student at UNC Chapel Hill concentrating in Land Use and Environmental Planning and is pursuing the Natural Hazards Resilience Certificate. She immigrated to the United States from Tamil Nadu, India as a kid and her family currently lives in Charlotte, North Carolina. In her free time, Josephine enjoys reading, traveling, and learning graphic design and sewing. After graduating she hopes to pursue a career in disaster management and coastal resiliency in California.


Looking for another opportunity to share your work? Submit to the CPJ Cover Photo contest!

The Carolina Planning Journal is now accepting submissions for the cover photo of this year’s journal, and we’d love to feature your image! Submissions should be related to this year’s journal theme, Planning for Healthy Cities. Examples of previous cover images can be found at the journal’s online repository. If your photo is selected for the cover, you will receive $100 for the rights to use it in the journal as well as photo attribution.

To enter submit your high-resolution (min. 300 dpi) photo to carolinaplanningjournal@gmail.com with the subject “CPJ Cover Photo Submission,” along with a brief explanation of how your image relates to the journal’s theme. Contact the Journal with any further questions.

Announcing the Carolina Angles Winter Photo Contest

Do you have winter travel plans? Preparing for a holiday staycation? Either way, Carolina Angles invites you to participate in our Winter Photo Contest!

We encourage UNC planning students, alumni, and all urban enthusiasts to enter. Photos will be judged based on aesthetics as well the articulated connection to planning.

The photographer of the winning photo will receive:

  • Recognition in the Carolina Planning Journal and Angles blog
  • Pre-order of Volume 47 of the Carolina Planning Journal, Planning for Healthy Cities (published in Spring 2022)
  • Carolina Planning Journal swag

Please use this google form to submit your photo and a brief blurb with how it relates to planning by Friday, January 28, 2022 at 5:00pm.

We look forward to your entries!

Featured Image courtesy of Pexels